fix window setback logic for multiple windows, fix 2

apps/rules/impl/window_setback.py

@@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ class WindowSetbackObjects(BaseModel):
     thermostats: list[str] = Field(..., min_length=1, description="Thermostats to control")
 
 
+
 class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
     """
     Window setback automation rule.
@@ -31,15 +32,13 @@ class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
             thermostats: List of thermostat device IDs to control (required, min 1)
         params:
             eco_target: Temperature to set when window opens (default: 16.0)
-            open_min_secs: Minimum seconds window must be open before triggering (default: 20)
-            close_min_secs: Minimum seconds window must be closed before restoring (default: 20)
             previous_target_ttl_secs: How long to remember previous temperature (default: 86400)
     
     State storage (Redis keys):
-        rule:{rule_id}:contact:{device_id}:state -> "open" | "closed"
-        rule:{rule_id}:contact:{device_id}:ts -> ISO timestamp of last change
         rule:{rule_id}:thermo:{device_id}:current_target -> Current target temp (updated on every STATE)
         rule:{rule_id}:thermo:{device_id}:previous -> Previous target temp (saved on window open, deleted on restore)
+        rule:{rule_id}:contact:{device_id}:is_open -> "1" if open, "0" if closed    
+        rule:{rule_id}:state -> Overall rule state -> "1" if thermostats set to eco, "0" otherwise
             
     Logic:
         1. Thermostat STATE events → update current_target in Redis
@@ -47,6 +46,41 @@ class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
         3. Window closes → restore from previous, then delete previous key
     """
 
+    @staticmethod
+    def __get_redis_key_current_target(rule_id: str, thermo_id: str) -> str:
+        """Get Redis key for current target temperature of a thermostat"""
+        return f"rule:{rule_id}:thermo:{thermo_id}:current_target"
+    @staticmethod
+    def __get_redis_key_previous_target(rule_id: str, thermo_id: str) -> str:
+        """Get Redis key for previous target temperature of a thermostat"""
+        return f"rule:{rule_id}:thermo:{thermo_id}:previous"
+    @staticmethod
+    def __get_redis_key_contact_state(rule_id: str, contact_id: str) -> str:
+        """Get Redis key for contact sensor state"""
+        return f"rule:{rule_id}:contact:{contact_id}:is_open"
+    @staticmethod
+    def __get_redis_key_rule_state(rule_id: str) -> str:
+        """Get Redis key for overall rule state"""
+        return f"rule:{rule_id}:state"
+    @staticmethod
+    async def __redis_get(ctx: RuleContext, key: str) -> Any:
+        """Helper to get value from Redis"""
+        v = await ctx.redis.get(key)
+        ctx.logger.debug(f"Redis GET {key} -> {v}")
+        return v
+    @staticmethod
+    async def __redis_set(ctx: RuleContext, key: str, value: Any) -> None:
+        """Helper to set value in Redis"""
+        ctx.logger.debug(f"Redis SET {key} = {value}")       
+        await ctx.redis.set(key, value)
+    @staticmethod
+    async def __redis_delete(ctx: RuleContext, key: str) -> None:
+        """Helper to delete key from Redis"""
+        ctx.logger.debug(f"Redis DEL {key}")
+        await ctx.redis.delete(key)
+
+
+
     def __init__(self):
         super().__init__()
         self._validated_objects: dict[str, WindowSetbackObjects] = {}
@@ -124,49 +158,54 @@ class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
         """Handle contact sensor state change."""
         device_id = evt['device_id']
         contact_state = evt['payload'].get('contact')  # "open" or "closed"
-        event_ts = evt.get('ts', ctx.now().isoformat())
         
         if not contact_state:
             ctx.logger.warning(f"Contact event missing 'contact' field: {evt}")
             return
                 
-        # Store current state and timestamp
-        state_key = f"rule:{desc.id}:contact:{device_id}:state"
-        ts_key = f"rule:{desc.id}:contact:{device_id}:ts"
+        contact_state_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_contact_state(desc.id, device_id)
+        await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_set(ctx, contact_state_key, '1' if contact_state == 'open' else '0')
 
-        await ctx.redis.set(state_key, contact_state)
-        await ctx.redis.set(ts_key, event_ts)
+        # Check if any contact is open
+        is_open = False
+        for contact_id in desc.objects.get('contacts', []):
+            state_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_contact_state(desc.id, contact_id)
+            state_val = await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_get(ctx, state_key)
+            if state_val == '1':
+                is_open = True
+                break
 
-        if contact_state == 'open':
-            await self._on_window_opened(desc, ctx)
-        elif contact_state == 'closed':
-            await self._on_window_closed(desc, ctx)
+        rule_state_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_rule_state(desc.id)
+        current_rule_state = await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_get(ctx, rule_state_key)
+        if is_open and current_rule_state != '1':
+            # At least one contact is open, and we are not already in eco mode
+            await self._set_eco_mode(desc, ctx)
+            await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_set(ctx, rule_state_key, '1')
+        elif not is_open and current_rule_state != '0':
+            # All contacts are closed, and we are currently in eco mode
+            await self._unset_eco_mode(desc, ctx)
+            await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_set(ctx, rule_state_key, '0')
 
-    async def _on_window_opened(self, desc: RuleDescriptor, ctx: RuleContext) -> None:
-        """
-        Window opened - save current temperatures, then set thermostats to eco.
 
-        Important: We must save the current target BEFORE setting to eco,
-        otherwise we'll save the eco temperature instead of the original.
-        """
-        eco_target = desc.params.get('eco_target', 16.0)
+    async def _set_eco_mode(self, desc: RuleDescriptor, ctx: RuleContext) -> None:
+        """Set thermostats to eco temperature when window opens."""
+        eco_target = desc.params.get('eco_target', 7.0)
         target_thermostats = desc.objects.get('thermostats', [])
-        ttl_secs = desc.params.get('previous_target_ttl_secs', 86400)
         
         ctx.logger.info(
-            f"Rule {desc.id}: Window opened, setting {len(target_thermostats)} "
+            f"Rule {desc.id}: At least one window is opened, setting {len(target_thermostats)} "
             f"thermostats to eco temperature {eco_target}°C"
         )
         
         # FIRST: Save current target temperatures as "previous" (before we change them!)
         for thermo_id in target_thermostats:
-            current_key = f"rule:{desc.id}:thermo:{thermo_id}:current_target"
-            current_temp_str = await ctx.redis.get(current_key)
+            current_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_current_target(desc.id, thermo_id)
+            current_temp_str = await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_get(ctx, current_key)
             
             if current_temp_str:
                 # Save current as previous (with TTL)
-                prev_key = f"rule:{desc.id}:thermo:{thermo_id}:previous"
-                await ctx.redis.set(prev_key, current_temp_str, ttl_secs=ttl_secs)
+                prev_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_previous_target(desc.id, thermo_id)
+                await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_set(ctx, prev_key, current_temp_str)
                 ctx.logger.debug(
                     f"Saved previous target for {thermo_id}: {current_temp_str}°C"
                 )
@@ -183,24 +222,20 @@ class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
             except Exception as e:
                 ctx.logger.error(f"Failed to set {thermo_id}: {e}")
 
-    async def _on_window_closed(self, desc: RuleDescriptor, ctx: RuleContext) -> None:
-        """
-        Window closed - restore previous temperatures.
 
-        Note: This is simplified. A production implementation would check
-        close_min_secs and use a timer/scheduler.
-        """
+    async def _unset_eco_mode(self, desc: RuleDescriptor, ctx: RuleContext) -> None:
+        """Restore thermostats to previous temperature when window closes."""
         target_thermostats = desc.objects.get('thermostats', [])
         
         ctx.logger.info(
-            f"Rule {desc.id}: Window closed, restoring {len(target_thermostats)} "
+            f"Rule {desc.id}: All windows closed, restoring {len(target_thermostats)} "
             f"thermostats to previous temperatures"
         )
         
         # Restore previous temperatures
         for thermo_id in target_thermostats:
-            prev_key = f"rule:{desc.id}:thermo:{thermo_id}:previous"
-            prev_temp_str = await ctx.redis.get(prev_key)
+            prev_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_previous_target(desc.id, thermo_id)
+            prev_temp_str = await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_get(ctx, prev_key)
             
             if prev_temp_str:
                 try:
@@ -209,7 +244,7 @@ class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
                     ctx.logger.debug(f"Restored {thermo_id} to {prev_temp}°C")
                     
                     # Delete the previous key after restoring
-                    await ctx.redis.delete(prev_key)
+                    await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_delete(ctx, prev_key)
                 except Exception as e:
                     ctx.logger.error(f"Failed to restore {thermo_id}: {e}")
             else:
@@ -240,10 +275,8 @@ class WindowSetbackRule(Rule):
             return  # No target in this state update
         
         # Store current target (always update, even if it's the eco temperature)
-        current_key = f"rule:{desc.id}:thermo:{device_id}:current_target"
-        ttl_secs = desc.params.get('previous_target_ttl_secs', 86400)
-        
-        await ctx.redis.set(current_key, str(current_target), ttl_secs=ttl_secs)
+        current_key = WindowSetbackRule.__get_redis_key_current_target(desc.id, device_id)
+        await WindowSetbackRule.__redis_set(ctx, current_key, str(current_target))
         
         ctx.logger.debug(
             f"Rule {desc.id}: Updated current target for {device_id}: {current_target}°C"